In the fall of 2024, Mariano Grana told The Hinsdalean who his best marketers were. They were middle-schoolers buying slices and hot dogs at Brasi's Pizzeria on Hinsdale Avenue after school. "They are the best because they go home and tell their parents, and the parents come in an order food," he said.
That slice counter handles one kind of pizza night. Downtown Hinsdale has a different place for a square-cut tavern pie at a bar on Monday, for a family booth on Friday, and for a crust you finish in your own oven after the evening train, and the places don't overlap much. Each one bakes its own style and sells it its own way. That helps most in Thanksgiving week, when a house full of guests on Wednesday night may want three kinds of pizza.
Here is downtown's pizza, sorted by the job each place does best.
The space at 8 E. First St. belonged to Il Poggiolo for 17 years. According to Time Out Chicago, the locally owned restaurant closed in June 2025, and Ballyhoo Hospitality chose the space for its third DeNucci's, after Lincoln Park and Highland Park. DeNucci's Hinsdale site now takes reservations and takeout and delivery orders at that address. The building has its own history. It is one of the downtown storefronts covered in our post on the paint store, gas station and post office R. Harold Zook designed.
The everyday pies at DeNucci's are 16-inch New York-style, starting with a $22 cheese and running to $31 for the tartufo on the dinner menu dated early November 2026. Time Out reported that those pies come by way of the North Shore's Pizza by Sal.
Mondays are different. The menu lists "monday chicago tavern style pizza" as the first entry in its day-by-day specials, ahead of Tuesday lasagna and Sunday's family-style dinner for four. The restaurant's tavern menu gives the style's origin: thin and crispy, born on Chicago's South Side in the 1940s, square-cut, red-sauced and "designed to be shared amongst bargoers." Time Out reported that on tavern night, diners can build their own pie or order any of the red-sauce pizzas on the Chicago-style thin crust. The Monday special is listed at market price, so ask before you order. DeNucci's also makes gluten-free Sicilian-style pizzas, which helps when one person at the table can't eat a regular crust.
The next tavern Monday is November 23, two days before Thanksgiving Eve.
Brasi's Pizzeria opened at 34 E. Hinsdale Ave. in March 2024. Grana also runs a Lisle location, which The Hinsdalean reported had opened about three years before the Hinsdale shop. He told the paper he hadn't set out to open in Hinsdale: "We just saw the opportunity and kind of ran with it."
The menu runs from traditional cheese to specialty pies like the spicy Sicilian, Hawaiian and capricciosa. Grana said the margherita, made with plum tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil and tomatoes, was the early best-seller. The shop does carryout, delivery and catering, and it sells pizza by the slice. Its other draw, according to The Hinsdalean, is the cremino, a frozen espresso drink people carry around town in small cups. You can schedule an order ahead on its online ordering page, which is handy if you want to pick up dinner on a specific day this week.
Altamura Pizza at 9 W. First St. is the only place on this list built mainly for your own oven. It describes itself as a take-home-and-bake pizza and specialty shop. Its crust is imported from Puglia, made from the durum semolina wheat of Altamura, and hand-tossed and stone-baked by Italian pizzaioli before it reaches Hinsdale. The owners call themselves first-generation Italians cooking the food of their hometown.
The shop's website plans around the Metra. It points out that the shop is close to the train station and suggests calling your order in so it's ready when you get off the train. If your oven is already full of pie crusts and a turkey breast, Altamura also sells baked pizzas. Its online menu this month has a vodka pizza and a baked meatball pizza on a mascarpone base, both starting at $17.95.
Altamura also sells slices that are hard to find elsewhere downtown. On the current menu, a regular slice with rotating toppings is $5.50, a focaccia Siciliana slice is $7, and a pinsa Romana slice is $9.50. The pinsa uses a rice-flour blend and is topped with house basil pesto, sun-dried tomatoes, burrata and balsamic. Brasi's slice is an after-school snack. The pinsa is more of a lunch.
Giuliano's Pizza at 40 Village Place has been around longer than anywhere else on this list. Miklos and Cathy Weisz opened it in April 1998. Miklos came to it with restaurant experience and a culinary arts degree from Kendall College. In July 2007 the restaurant expanded next door to create Giuliano's Ristorante, a dining room with a larger menu and more beer and wine. The website still opens with "Hinsdale's pizza night, since 1998." It also has recipe videos with Miklos, Cathy and other family members.
Giuliano's is the place to go for heavier crusts. Its carryout and delivery menu lists thin crust, Sicilian-style pan and stuffed pizza, plus an individual stuffed pizza or calzone. It's also the only spot on this list that does dine-in, carryout, delivery and catering. The site describes the dining room as family-friendly, and reservations go through Resy. When cousins land on Wednesday night and nobody wants to clean up, the booth is one option and the stuffed pie headed home is another.
Fuller House at 35 E. First St. is a downtown tavern first. Its name honors one of the town's first settlers, the same family name found at Fullersburg Woods. Its food menu has a short wood-fired Neapolitan section of 10-inch pies. There is a margherita with fresh mozzarella and basil, an Italian sausage and giardiniera, a pepperoni and ricotta with hot honey, and a Nueske bacon pizza with caramelized shallots, fig preserves and goat cheese. At 10 inches, it's a pizza for one person at a bar seat or a shared plate at a big table. Pickup orders run through its Toast page.
Put the menus side by side and the night before Thanksgiving splits into separate jobs. For the household that wants to eat out before the cooking starts, DeNucci's and Giuliano's both take reservations. For a crowd at home, Giuliano's catering menu and DeNucci's 16-inch pies cover the most people per box. For whoever is arriving on a late train, Altamura is set up for a phone order picked up on the way home from the station. For the teenagers who come home from school before anyone else, there's the slice counter on Hinsdale Avenue.
Every one of these is a style choice as much as a location choice. Tavern, New York, Sicilian pan, stuffed, wood-fired Neapolitan and Puglian semolina all bake in downtown Hinsdale. A house that can't agree on one pie can order from two places.
Holiday-week hours can shift, so call the shop before you count on a Wednesday pickup time. The village's Holiday Express now runs on Thanksgiving Sunday, and the Christmas Walk comes five days later.
The team at Second City Agents keeps track of downtown Hinsdale storefronts, from the 8 E. First St. turnover to the next new sign on Hinsdale Avenue. If you're thinking about what a home near the depot and these blocks is worth, schedule a free market consultation and we'll walk you through what's selling nearby.